Very good arc here, all the good supernatural, psychological intrigue, with hardly any of the annoying ecchi aspect. Praise.
Hanamonogatari
Monogatari Series: Second Season
It's worth slogging through Nisemonogatari and Nekomonogatari to get here. Fantastic arcs.
Nisemonogatari
Too much inexcusable uncomfortable fan-service (read borderline illegal) to make the neat dialogue worth it. It is important to the overarching Monogatari story, so if you're embarking on it, muscle through.
Bakemonogatari
A delightfully artsy and philosophical adventure, truly unique.
Sword Art Online II (Season 2)
This season goes deeper into the psyche of the characters and explores the concept of Virtual Reality applications, ramifications, while also showing both the benefits and risks of immersing oneself online.
Fate/Zero
A gripping, gritty modern fantasy with fascinating psychological and historical elements.
Puella Magi Madoka Magica: Rebellion
An eerie finish (?) to the Madoka series that keeps the curveballs coming. Inu Curry's unsettling abstract animation is back and Yuki Kajiura's soundtrack is phenomenal, but the story can be tricky to follow.
Puella Magi Madoka Magica
Do you ever have those shows or games that you go through and they just stick with you for like, months? This is one of those.
Kakegurui
If you’re looking for a rush, Kakegurui won’t disappoint. If you’re wanting to stay comfortable, give it a pass. I'd liken this to very spicy or strong ethnic food: You either love it and get hooked, or you hate it.
At a Glance Anime 