Despite having a cut and dry predictable romcom plot, the character development here is surprisingly great, as are all of the characters. We found ourselves tremendously invested.
Toradora!
Love is Like a Cocktail
With only 3-minute episodes, I'd hoped for more of the content to be about describing/presenting the drinks. There's some slice of life content here, but it feels a bit rushed and shallow.
Your Lie in April
If you grew up learning any instrument, or even just surrounded by music, specifically classical, this will be a great piece for you. Deeply emotional and poetic, prepare for the cries (and for some distracting tropes).
Ouran High School Host Club
This is a fun and funny "snack" show. There isn't too much substance to it, but it's a fun enjoyable reverse harem while you're there.
At a Glance Anime 